As
I was reading the information for the copyrights and fair use assignment, my
mind kept thinking about the poem that begins Ernest Hemingway’s novel, For
Whom the Bell Tolls. For those of you
who are not familiar with this novel, Hemingway starts the novel with a poem by
John Donne, written in an archaic form of English. The part of the poem that resonates with me
is the beginning where Donne writes, “No man is an Iland, intire of it selfe;
every man is a peece of the Continent, a part of the maine…”(Donne, 1940). As this relates to creativity and original
works, this means that no one who creates, creates alone, in a vacuum, devoid
of the influence of other people.
Practically,
creativity is spawned by the people, culture, and ideas of those that we allow
into our sphere of attention. In this
way, every person creates their own understanding of the unique experiences of the world that they live in. These unique experiences would not be possible
without the thoughts and experiences of others.
Original thoughts and ideas are born on the thoughts and ideas of others
in a sort of human culture amalgam.
However,
ideas are where the law draws the line.
If you go beyond ideas and copy someone else’s work wholesale, and try
to pass it off as your own, at the very least it is plagiarism, and at its
worst is theft. Not only is this
practice theft, but it is also lying. Regardless
of the law, ethically it is wrong.
Unfortunately,
it is becoming more evident every day that the law is just words when it comes
to this subject. If those words are not
enforced, then the words of the law are empty and do not amount to the value of
the ink (or electrons) used to portray their meaning. This seems to be where our culture is heading
in the information revolution. Now, anyone
with a computer and mouse can clip, snag, screen capture, and crop any digital
representation of anyone’s hard work with a few clicks and taps.
For
these reasons, I liked learning about how creative commons licenses can help
keep the balance of protecting creator’s works, yet unleashing the potential tangential
ideas that other creators can use to add to the amalgamation of culture. Creative commons licenses keep creators in
control of their works, so they can decide how and what works of theirs will be
used. Even though it is not a one stop
fix to intellectual theft, it is a beginning to unleash creativity. In this way, we are better together. Again, “No man is an iland, intire of it selfe…”
(Donne, 1940).
References
Donne, J. (1940). No Man is an Iland.
In E. Hemmingway, For Whom the Bell Tolls (p. 1). New York,
NY: Quality Paperback Book Club